In the fitness community, debates often center around the merits of aerobic versus resistance training. Which is more effective? Which should you prioritize? The truth is, as these four studies demonstrate, combining aerobic and resistance training offers unparalleled benefits across various populations. Whether you’re sedentary, overweight, older, or simply looking to improve your overall fitness, integrating both forms of exercise into your routine can lead to significant improvements in strength, body composition, cardiovascular health, and overall functional ability.
1. Mitigating Frailty in Obese Older Adults
Older adults, particularly those who are obese, often face the dual challenges of declining muscle mass and increased fat accumulation. Frailty, characterized by reduced physical performance, is a common consequence. A study conducted by Villareal et al. (2017) found that a combined regimen of aerobic and resistance training not only improved physical function but also helped preserve lean mass better than either modality alone. This combination was more effective in reducing frailty, making it a crucial approach for maintaining independence in older adults.
2. Enhancing Body Composition in Sedentary Individuals
Sedentary lifestyles are a significant contributor to poor health outcomes, including obesity and metabolic disorders. In a study by Mann et al. (2018), participants who engaged in structured and supervised resistance training showed significant improvements in both strength and body composition. The results were particularly pronounced when resistance training was combined with aerobic exercise, demonstrating the value of a multi-faceted approach in addressing the health risks associated with sedentarism.
3. Improving Physical Fitness in Obese Men
Obesity is a global epidemic, and its management often requires more than just weight loss. Jin et al. (2018) investigated the effects of combining aerobic and resistance training on inflammatory markers in obese men. The study revealed that this combined approach significantly improved body composition and physical fitness while reducing inflammation, a key factor in many obesity-related diseases. This highlights the importance of a dual-modality exercise program in combating the complex issues associated with obesity.
4. Targeting Hidden Obesity in College Students
Hidden obesity, where individuals appear to have a normal weight but possess a high body fat percentage, is increasingly recognized as a health risk. Liu (2020) explored the effects of an aerobics and strength training intervention on “invisible obese” college students. The findings indicated that combining aerobic and resistance training significantly improved body composition, including reductions in skinfold thickness and body fat percentage, while enhancing strength and flexibility. This approach offers a comprehensive solution for managing hidden obesity in younger populations.
5. Preserving Bone Mineral Density in Aging Populations
Bone health is a critical concern, particularly in older adults. As people age, bone mineral density (BMD) tends to decline, increasing the risk of osteoporosis and fractures. The study by Villareal et al. (2017) found that while aerobic exercise alone was associated with a decrease in BMD, combining it with resistance training attenuated this loss. This underscores the importance of incorporating resistance exercises into fitness regimens for aging populations to help maintain bone health.
6. Maximizing Cardiovascular and Strength Benefits in At-Risk Populations
Populations at risk for conditions like type 2 diabetes often require targeted interventions to improve both cardiovascular health and muscular strength. In Mann et al.’s second study (2018), the combination of aerobic and resistance training was particularly effective in increasing strength and improving body composition in overweight and pre-diabetic individuals. The dual approach provided comprehensive benefits, addressing both cardiovascular and metabolic health simultaneously.
7. Achieving Comprehensive Fitness Outcomes in Diverse Populations
The overarching theme across these studies is the unmatched versatility of combining aerobic and resistance training. Whether addressing frailty in the elderly, obesity in adults, or hidden obesity in young adults, this approach consistently yields superior outcomes. The evidence suggests that regardless of the population or specific health concerns, integrating these two forms of exercise leads to improved physical performance, better body composition, and enhanced overall health.
All Based on the Study Findings
Study 1: The Power of Combined Exercise in Obese Older Adults
Obesity in older adults is a growing concern, often leading to frailty and a decline in physical function. However, weight loss alone can accelerate the loss of muscle and bone mass, leading to sarcopenia and osteopenia. In a comprehensive clinical trial involving 160 obese older adults, researchers explored how different exercise modes could counteract these effects. The participants were randomly assigned to a weight-management program combined with either aerobic training, resistance training, or a combination of both, or to a control group.
The results were striking. The group that participated in both aerobic and resistance training saw the most significant improvements in physical function and reductions in frailty. Specifically, the combination group experienced a 21% increase in Physical Performance Test scores, surpassing the gains seen in the groups that engaged in aerobic or resistance training alone. Additionally, this group preserved more lean mass and attenuated the loss of bone mineral density at the hip, making it the most effective intervention for improving overall health and functionality in obese older adults.
Study 2: Aerobics Combined with Strength Training for Invisible Obese College Students
Invisible obesity, characterized by a seemingly normal weight but high body fat percentage, is a silent health threat, particularly among young adults. In a study involving 28 college students with invisible obesity, researchers tested the effects of combining aerobics with strength training over six weeks. The students were randomly divided into an observation group, which followed the combined training program, and a control group, which adhered to a routine training regimen.
The findings revealed that the combined training group significantly improved their body composition, reducing body fat percentage and increasing muscle mass. Moreover, the participants in this group demonstrated better strength and flexibility outcomes compared to the control group. These results underscore the importance of integrating both aerobic and resistance exercises to effectively combat invisible obesity and improve overall physical health in young adults.
Study 3: Community Fitness Programs and Their Impact on Strength and Body Composition
In a world where physical inactivity is a public health crisis, community fitness programs offer a promising solution. Two randomized trials involving sedentary adults and overweight, pre-diabetic individuals were conducted to assess the impact of structured resistance training (RT) on strength and body composition. Participants in the first study were offered either a structured exercise program, free gym access, or physical activity counseling, while the second study compared traditional supervised exercise, physical activity counseling, and a combination of both.
Both studies found that participants engaging in structured or supervised RT experienced significant increases in strength. However, it was the groups with programmed and supervised RT that showed notable improvements in body composition, particularly in lean body mass and reductions in body fat percentage. These findings highlight the critical role of structured resistance training, especially when combined with aerobic exercise, in enhancing health outcomes in sedentary and at-risk populations.
Study 4: Effects of Combined Aerobic and Resistance Training on Inflammatory Markers in Obese Men
Inflammation is a key driver of many chronic diseases associated with obesity. In a study examining the effects of combined aerobic and resistance training on inflammatory markers in obese men, researchers sought to determine whether this training approach could reduce inflammation and improve overall health. Seventeen obese men were randomly divided into two groups: one followed an aerobic training regimen, while the other engaged in combined aerobic and resistance training.
After eight weeks, the combined training group not only showed significant improvements in body composition but also experienced a marked reduction in the inflammatory marker TNF-alpha. This reduction was directly correlated with decreases in body fat percentage. The study concluded that combining aerobic and resistance exercises offers a powerful intervention for reducing inflammation and improving health outcomes in obese individuals.
The Takeaway: Why You Should Combine Aerobic and Resistance Training
Across diverse populations—from older adults to young college students, from the sedentary to those at risk of chronic disease—these studies consistently show that combining aerobic and resistance training yields the most significant health benefits. This approach not only improves strength and body composition but also enhances cardiovascular health, reduces inflammation, and mitigates the risks associated with obesity and inactivity.
For fitness enthusiasts, athletes, and anyone looking to optimize their health, the evidence is clear: a well-rounded fitness routine that includes both aerobic and resistance training is essential. Whether your goal is to improve functional ability, maintain independence, or simply stay fit, integrating both forms of exercise into your regimen will provide the most comprehensive benefits.
References:
- Villareal, D.T., Aguirre, L., Gurney, A.B., et al. (2017). Aerobic or Resistance Exercise, or Both, in Dieting Obese Older Adults. New England Journal of Medicine, 376(20), 1943-1955. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1616338.
- Liu, Q. (2020). Effect of Aerobics Combined with Strength Training Intervention on Invisible Obese College Students. Matrix Science Medica, 4(2), 32-34. DOI: 10.4103/MTSM.MTSM_10_19.
- Mann, S., Jimenez, A., Steele, J., et al. (2018). Programming and supervision of resistance training leads to positive effects on strength and body composition: results from two randomised trials of community fitness programmes. BMC Public Health, 18, Article 420. DOI: 10.1186/s12889-018-5333-z.
- Jin, C.H., Rhyu, H.S., Kim, J.Y. (2018). The effects of combined aerobic and resistance training on inflammatory markers in obese men. Journal of Exercise Rehabilitation, 14(4), 660-665. DOI: 10.12965/jer.1836294.147.
EXERCISES
