Learned helplessness is a psychological phenomenon where an individual who has been exposed to repeated negative or uncontrollable events eventually comes to believe that they have no control over the situation, even when they might actually have the power to change it. This belief can lead to feelings of helplessness, passivity, and depression, as the individual feels that any efforts to improve their circumstances would be futile.
The concept was first studied by psychologists Martin Seligman and Steven Maier in the 1960s through experiments with animals. Later, it was applied to human behavior to explain certain patterns of failure or passivity in the face of adversity, such as chronic stress, depression, or academic failure.
In practical terms, someone who experiences learned helplessness might stop trying to overcome challenges or improve situations, even when opportunities arise that could lead to positive outcomes. It can be especially debilitating in areas like education, work, or personal relationships.
The more I looked into this phenomenon, the more I could see the link to the struggles people have with their fitness and nutrition goals. This was a very intriguing topic to dive into.
I’m convinced that learned helplessness can have a profound impact on people’s fitness and nutrition goals, often leading to a cycle of repeated failure and demotivation. Now, I’ll admit this can be a complex issue overlapping other factors. When individuals face challenging goals in these areas, such as strict dieting or intense workout regimens, they can quickly become overwhelmed if they don’t see progress—or worse, if they experience repeated failure. Over time, this experience can create a repeatable pattern that conditions them to believe they are inherently incapable of achieving their fitness or nutrition goals, even when their methods or approaches are the actual issue. When you fail repeatedly, you begin to expect failure.
How Difficult Dieting Leads to Learned Helplessness
Many people, especially those who jump into extreme or unsustainable diets, can experience early setbacks. Common problems include:
Crash diets or extreme caloric restriction: These are difficult to maintain long-term, often causing physical and mental exhaustion, hunger, and even binge eating episodes. When the diet inevitably breaks down, the person feels like a failure, reinforcing the belief that dieting is beyond their control.
Yo-yo dieting: The cycle of losing and regaining weight can be emotionally draining. Each failure erodes self-confidence and creates the perception that no matter what they do, they cannot sustain a healthy weight or lifestyle.
Unrealistic expectations: Many people expect rapid results, and when progress is slower than expected, they perceive it as failure, even though their progress may be on track. The repeated feeling of “doing everything right” but still failing contributes to the learned helplessness mindset.
In this state, individuals begin to believe that no diet will work for them, even if they later try more reasonable approaches. This belief causes them to either give up entirely or approach dieting with little effort, expecting failure from the start.
How Doing Too Much Too Soon in the Gym Causes Learned Helplessness
Similarly, fitness goals can fall into the trap of learned helplessness, especially for beginners or those restarting after a long hiatus:
Overtraining or overwhelming workouts: Many people, motivated by rapid change, jump into workout programs that are too intense for their current fitness level. This can lead to burnout, injury, or feeling defeated when they can’t complete the workout or progress as expected. The body and mind become fatigued, reinforcing the idea that they are not cut out for fitness.
Lack of visible progress: Early gym-goers may struggle with seeing tangible results, particularly if they focus on outcomes like weight loss or visible muscle gain, which can take time. When they don’t see results fast enough, they may feel their efforts are pointless.
Comparison to others: Comparing their progress to more advanced gym-goers can exacerbate feelings of inadequacy. When they can’t lift as much or run as fast, they internalize this as a personal failure rather than recognizing it as part of the journey.
These experiences often culminate in the belief that no matter how hard they try, they won’t succeed in getting stronger or fitter. This mindset can lead to inconsistent effort, avoidance of the gym, or even quitting entirely, reinforcing the cycle of failure.
Breaking the Cycle of Learned Helplessness in Fitness and Nutrition
To prevent or overcome learned helplessness, it’s crucial to shift how people approach fitness and nutrition:
Create the win: Set yourself up to be successful with realistic, manageable goals. Encourage small, achievable goals rather than drastic changes. Allow the wins to create a pattern of success. In fitness, this might mean starting with manageable workouts that are well structured and appropriate for your fitness level and objectives, then gradually increasing intensity. In nutrition, it could mean gradual dietary changes instead of extreme restrictions that lead to feelings of deprivation and starvation.
Focus on process over outcomes: Instead of fixating on weight loss or muscle gain, focus on the behavior itself—consistently showing up at the gym, eating more nutritious foods. Successful people leave clues. These clues are not “secrets” or special “hacks” that somehow create miraculous results; only through effort and time can you achieve anything of value. When we make the process the goal, the results will follow in time. Of course, this means learning patience in place of learning helplessness.
Celebrate small victories: Emphasize the importance of small victories, like finishing a workout or sticking to a nutrition plan for a day. Each success reinforces the idea that progress is possible. One successful day building on the next.
Avoid perfectionism: Promote the understanding that setbacks are a normal part of any fitness or nutrition journey. By reframing failures as learning opportunities rather than definitive signs of personal inadequacy, individuals can avoid the mindset of helplessness.
Gradual progression: Build up to harder workouts or stricter nutritional changes slowly to prevent burnout. This prevents the overwhelming feelings that often lead to the belief that one “can’t” succeed.
By addressing the root causes of learned helplessness in fitness and nutrition, individuals can build confidence in their ability to make progress, ultimately breaking the cycle of failure. The key is patience, sustainable changes, and a shift in mindset from “all or nothing” to steady, consistent improvement.
EXERCISE
